Welcome|
Assignment #5(a)|
MIE165S Assignment #5(a) Solution
Q#1:
(a) Profit is set to be at least $120,000. Only M3 and M4 satisfies this
condition. Also maximum loss is set to be $40,000. From M3 and M4, only M4
satisifies this condition. So only M4 satisfies both of the aspiration
level constraints. Our decision will be M4.
(b) According to the expert the most probable market need for the product
is 6 years that corresponds to S3, with the probability of 0.4. With this
approach our decision will be M3 since it earns most for the market
condition of S3.
(c) The expected values of each machine can be determined as follows:
M1 = (100*0.2+90*0.3+80*0.4+70*0.1) * 1000 = $ 86,000
M2 = (60*0.2+110*0.3+110*0.4+90*0.1) * 1000 = $ 98,000
M3 = ((-50)*0.2+90*0.3+150*0.4+140*0.1) * 1000 = $ 91,000
M4 = ((-30)*0.2+80*0.3+100*0.4+200*0.1) * 1000 = $ 78,000
So our decision will be M2.
(d) Since we are using the laplace criterion we will assume the nature to be
indifferent, and assign the probabiltiy of 1/n,(which corresponds to 1/4
for this problem) to each future. So we will look at the average profit for
each machine such as:
M1 = (100+90+80+70) * 1000*0.25 = $85,000
M2 = (60+110+110+90) * 1000*0.25 = $ 92,500
M3 = ((-50)+90+150+140) * 1000 *0.25= $ 57,500
M4 = ((-30)*+80+100+200) * 1000 *0.25= $ 87,500
So our decision would be M2.
(e) Maximum profits and minimum profits for each machine is as follows:
Alternative Min Max
M1 70 100
M2 60 110
M3 -50 150
M4 -30 200
So our Maximin decision would be M1, and Maximax decision would be M4.
(f) For the Hurwicz rule, alpha is given to be 0.4. Hurwicz rule requires
the computation of the following equation:
Alternatives
M1 (0.4*100+0.6*70)*1000= 82,000
M2 (0.4*110+0.6*60)*1000= 80,000
M3 (0.4*150+0.6*(-50))*1000= 20,000
M4 (0.4*200+0.6*(-30))*1000= 62,000
So our decision would be M1.